Annual Fee Credit on Closed Accounts
It’s a tale as old as time. You open a rewards credit card and use it a bit, but don’t get a lot of value out of it. At the end of the year the annual fee comes due and you decide to cancel before the payment due date. You then call the bank and are told the account is closed. Easy, right?
Well, not exactly. Believe it or not that annual fee is still a charge on the account and if it isn’t either paid or credited back, you can be charged late fees. If the problem persists long enough, it could show as a 30 day or more late payment on your credit as well. Are you at fault in such a situation? Probably not, but it is easier to avoid that problem than trying to fix it.
A Bank of America Blunder
My wife recently had such a thing happen to her when she called Bank of America and cancelled her Alaska business credit card. The rep said they would remove the annual fee and that nothing else needed to be done. She went on with her life until yesterday when she opened a piece of mail saying the account was almost 3 months past due!
I manage our credit card accounts online and almost always go in to make sure the annual fees have been credited back. Some banks take up to 30 days to credit back the fee, so I generally check around the statement due date and just pay the annual fee if it is still due. This results in a credit balance in the end and a check being mailed back to us, which I am fine with. This sytem has worked for many many years, but not this time!
My Failed System
So what happened in this situation? Unlike other banks who leave your credit card tied to your online profile when closing an account, Bank of America removes it altogether for closed accounts. (At least in my experience.) This means that I didn’t see the account when logging in and forgot to follow up on the annual fee. I have never actually had a time when the annual fee wasn’t credited back, but of course it would happen in the one situation where I wasn’t prompted to follow up.
Anyway, fast forward to yesterday where we received a bill for ~$151. This included the annual fee, a couple of late fees and interest charges on the annual fee and late fees. Thankfully my wife and I are Platinum Honors members with BofA which seems to get us a higher level of service. A quick call to an agent resulted in an apology and an assurance that all of the fees and late charges will be erased. We have already notated it on our calendars to follow up in a couple of days.
Your Credit Report
One of the most damaging things to a credit score can be late payments. In this case it was a business account which doesn’t show on my wife’s credit so nothing has been reported and thus nothing needs to be fixed. If it had gone to collections, then it most likely would have shown on her report.
If this situation were to occur with a personal credit card account, once the account is 30 days past due it will be reported to the credit bureaus. A single 30 day late can drop your score by 50-80 points depending on other factors. If a late is reported, the first thing you need to do is get the account fixed, then get a letter from the bank stating the account was never late. You can use that letter to dispute the reporting. You can also ask the bank to reverse their reporting as well.
Best Practices
When closing a credit card account there are a couple of things you can do to avoid late payment fees and dings on your credit report:
- Always confirm when the annual fee will be credited when closing an account.
- Add an “Annual Fee Credited” or “Confirmed Zero Balance” column to your tracking spreadsheet to ensure that your closed accounts are at a $0 balance. Check back within the timeframe you are told, to ensure the rep credited back the annual fee.
- If the annual fee becomes due and has not yet been credited, consider paying it, knowing you will get a check back. This is a personal preference since I’d rather do this than fight to get the fees fixed later.
- If a mistake has been made and your credit is affected, work with the bank to reverse the mistake, then push them to reverse the credit reporting. It is always a good idea to get a letter stating the account was not late, so you can dispute the reporting as well.
Conclusion
My previous system of manually checking closed accounts had worked for many years, but Bank of America’s practice of removing a closed account from online access threw a wrench into that. For now I have updated my tracking spreadsheet and will be a bit more diligent in making sure everything is closed out for good.
Have you had a similar problem with a bank? How was it resolved? Do you have any tips to share with others? Let us know in the comments!
Chase Sapphire Preferred® Card
Chase Sapphire Preferred® Card is the old king of travel rewards cards. Right now
bonus_miles_full
Learn more about this card and its features!
Opinions, reviews, analyses & recommendations are the author’s alone, and have not been reviewed, endorsed or approved by any of these entities.
[…] A Potentially Disastrous Reminder of Why You Need to Check Annual Fee Credits on Closed Accounts! […]
[…] ways you can screw up. Watch out when you close credit card accounts and then you find out you are months late in paying the annual fee. Bank of America does that more often than other banks […]
I also manage my wife’s and my accounts. Here is a system that has worked great for me: Log into all accounts once a week. Also, pay off annual fee right away, and have them mail you a check later for the credit.
Shawn, something similar just happened to me. The annual fee hit on a Barclay’s card. I called to close and I was told I had 60 days to pay. I decided after 30 days to close the account anyway (and I did pay the annual fee before closing). I got a credit alert three days ago that my credit score had dropped 80 points. Barclay’s reported the account as closed, with $0 owing, but a delinquent payment! I now have to write them to try to get it removed. Would have been far better just to pay the annual fee at the time it was due and decide later (within 60 days) as you suggested.
Can this issue be adverted if the card is closed at 11th month prior to the annual fee is charged?
Agreed, that seems like the easiest way!
Comenity(Virgin) took three calls over 60 days to get properly closed and late fees removed. Mint.com helped pick it up. Luckily, no adverse credit reports. Just lame.
I had the same thing happen to me with a credit card I cancelled and forgot about. I also received the letter in the mail after it was 3 months over due. After calling I got all of the fees reversed but it took a told on my credit score. Since then started using an app called Prosper Daily that allows me to manage and Track balances on all of my cards to include the cancelled cards. If a late fee pops up again the app will catch it and I can handle it before the forgotten account 90 days late.
Your reminder is potentially disastrous!