(Devaluation) I May Have Drained My Citi ThankYou Points With This New Redemption

This post may contain affiliate links; please read our advertiser disclosure for more information.

Shop Your Way

Gift Cards at Shop Your Way – Quirky Redemptions and Solid Value

Shop Your Way points can be redeemed for a variety of third-party gift cards, as Stephen at GCGalore and Greg/Nick at Frequent Miler have recently reported.  I have a Shop Your Way account that has been largely dormant, so I was curious to see how useful this type of redemption could be.  I was pleasantly surprised by some undeniable value one can obtain from these redemptions, albeit from the quirky Shop Your Way website.  After I summarize the deal, I’ll go over my initial observations of the capability and provide my overall take.

Update 11/16/20: Citi has devalued the transfer rate on ThankYou points from 1 ThankYou point for 12 Shop Your Way Rewards down to 1 for 10.  This lessons the value to a penny per ThankYou point most of the time which means it is probably not a worthwhile redemption for most any more.  HT FM

How Redemptions Work

Members can easily juice their Shop Your Way balances by transferring Citi ThankYou Points to Shop Your Way points at a 1:12 ratio.  Don’t get too excited – Shop Your Way points are worth one-tenth of a cent per point when redeemed for gift cards.  Long story short, 1 ThankYou point is worth 1.2 cents in gift cards via Shop Your Way redemptions.  Of course, those of you who hold the Shop Your Way credit card will also want to incorporate your earnings into any redemption equation, as well.  So, are these ThankYou to Shop Your Way transfers for Gift Card redemptions worth it?  It depends.  I’ll explain in my observations and overall take.

Shop Your Way

#1.  The Variety of Gift Cards at Shop Your Way

The gift card selection, in cooperation with Raise, is substantial and varied.  Along with the usual restaurant gift cards seemingly available on every redemption site, there are other great category options including food delivery, home improvement, department stores, and travel.  Here are a few non-travel gift cards that immediately caught my eye:

  • Google Play Store
  • Uber Eats
  • Ebay
  • GrubHub
  • Lowe’s
  • DoorDash
  • Barnes and Noble
  • Caribou Coffee
  • Walmart
  • Home Depot

#2.  Gift Cards in the Travel Category

Travel-related gift card selection is limited, but there are some useful options.  Here are all of the travel gift cards available:

The main highlights (to me) are Southwest Airlines, Hotels.com, and Uber.

#3.  Single Redemptions Are Fast and Smooth

From transferring Citi ThankYou points to actually receiving your gift card, the process is very quick.  My transfer of ThankYou points to Shop Your Way points showed up instantaneously.  After I made the ThankYou point transfer, my Shop Your Way points immediately appeared when I refreshed the website.  I redeemed my points for one Walmart gift card, and I immediately received it via email.  But why just “single” redemptions?  Because….

#4.  The Quirkiness of the Shop Your Way Website

The Shop Your Way website only allows one gift card per redemption order.  You can’t even pick more than one in quantity of the same gift card!  Also, gift card values mostly top out in the $45-50 denomination.  I only found one gift card for a value higher than that – a $100 Carnival Cruises gift card (no, thanks).

Shop Your Way

#5.  Good News For Citi Rewards+ Cardholders

As a Citi Rewards+ cardholder, I received my points back email a few minutes after my Shop Your Way redemption.  The card’s 10% points back feature on the first 100k of point redemptions effectively boosts the ThankYou point value from 1.2 cpp to 1.32 cpp.

Overall Take

I’m happy to have another solid option for redeeming ThankYou points, particularly when the Premier’s 25% extra point value disappears in April 2021.  If this Shop Your Way option continues indefinitely, I plan to continue these redemptions long term.  The one card redemption limit is a bit cumbersome, but the fast processing time of each order makes up for it, in my opinion.  For my plans, this is a great redemption, but Shop Your Way is making me work for it.

Others should carefully consider other discount gift card options (via grocery stores, promos, etc) prior to redeeming for a given brand on the site.  Those other discounts can effectively make a Shop Your Way redemption less valuable for a given redemption.  People who like to redeem for non-travel related rewards win big here, getting an additional 20% value (at least) from ThankYou points.

Gift Cards at Shop Your Way – Conclusion

Big picture, I assess these Shop Your Way redemptions as an overall positive.  I’m all for more options for redeeming rewards currencies, and this option creates more opportunities.  I’ll be more confident in this redemption option based on it’s long term stability.  Are you planning to redeem Shop Your Way points for gift cards?

Benjy Harmon
Benjy is a fan of points, miles, and financial independence (FI). An experienced world traveler, husband, and father, he currently focuses on roaming throughout the USA expense-free (or close to it). He enjoys helping others achieve their FI and travel goals.

More Like This


Responses are not provided or commissioned by the bank advertiser. Responses have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by the bank advertiser. It is not the bank advertiser's responsibility to ensure all posts and/or questions are answered.


  1. Thanks for this! I’ve been wondering whether to ‘spend’ some of my TY points or let them sit, but I wasn’t interested in anything unless it was more than a penny a point. This was perfect, even at just 1.2 cents per point, and I wouldn’t have tried if I hadn’t seen this article. It was an instantaneous transfer (though it took awhile to set up my account, because the ‘optional’ text they send is not optional at all) and an instant email with the gift card.

    I have DoorDash with my CSR, and added a gift card. For those curious, yes the gift card works with your CSR discounts, as long as you keep the CSR as the primary payment method.

    (Now to figure out if shopyourway is worth it in other ways)

    • Jason,

      I’m glad you’re getting value out of the redemption! In my opinion, this play is particularly intriguing because it can be useful to different people in so many varied ways. Have fun!


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here


  • MtM recommended tool to track & organize credit cards
  • Best card offers personalized for you
  • Track bonus deadlines, fee dates & 5/24 status
  • Full Travel Freely overview

Free Sign-Up

  • MtM recommended tool to track & organize credit cards
  • Best card offers personalized for you
  • Track bonus deadlines, fee dates & 5/24 status
  • Full Travel Freely overview

Free Sign-Up

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Join thousands of MtM readers who are subscribed to receive a once daily email with all of our posts. Never miss out!

You have Successfully Subscribed!