My CSR Upgrade Experience & My New Ultimate Rewards Game Plan

This post may contain affiliate links; please read our advertiser disclosure for more information.
Disclosure: Miles to Memories has partnered with CardRatings for our coverage of credit card products. Miles to Memories and CardRatings may receive a commission from card issuers. Opinions, reviews, analyses & recommendations are the author’s alone, and have not been reviewed, endorsed or approved by any of these entities. Links in this post may provide us with a commission.

Chase Sapphire Reserve Upgrade

My Chase Sapphire Reserve Upgrade and What’s Next

Chase surprised us with Friday’s announcement that Chase Sapphire Reserve and Sapphire Preferred cardholders can cash out Ultimate Rewards points with 50% and 25% more value respectively in certain categories.  I don’t think any of us saw that coming – I know I didn’t.  As I’ve previously described, I’m a fan of cashing out Ultimate Rewards points to travel exactly how I want.  I crunched the numbers, determined a Chase Sapphire Reserve upgrade was worth it, and further assessed spending opportunities.  Let’s go through my process!

My Upgrade Decision

Using a method similar to Mark,  I easily decided to upgrade to the Reserve.  Unlike Mark, I value the annual $60 DoorDash credit at about 90%.  I’m a fan of pickup at certain area restaurants where prices are comparable to walk-in restaurant rates, and I avoid ridiculous service and delivery charges.  I also value it higher because BonChon is available on DoorDash in my area!  So my upgrade math to determine my true cost ended up looking like this:

  • $550 CSR Annual Fee – $300 travel credit cash equivalent – ($120 DoorDash credits * 0.9) = $142 upgrade cost

With a $142 upgrade cost, I needed to cash out at least 28,400 points to cover my upgrade cost from a Chase Freedom.  My only personal Ultimate Rewards-earning cards are Freedom accounts, so I had no other upgrade options.  Another factor I considered is I have close to zero Ultimate Rewards points currently, since I actively cash out.  However, I safely estimated that I can earn at least 28,400 Ultimate Rewards points with my multiple Chase Ink Business Cash and Freedom card accounts by September 30th.  Also, I didn’t give serious consideration to upgrading to the Chase Sapphire Preferred because I routinely cash out at relatively high volumes.

My decision to upgrade to the Chase Sapphire Reserve was also clear because I had already hit the maximum spend on this quarter’s 5% grocery bonus category for the Freedom card account which I wanted to upgrade.  Also, my wife and I would still have four other active Freedom accounts to take advantage of quarterly bonus categories.

Chase Sapphire Reserve Upgrade

The Chase Sapphire Reserve Upgrade Process

I had decided to upgrade the Freedom account which was originally my first Chase Sapphire Reserve account.  Previously, I had downgraded my Reserve to a Freedom when Chase removed Disney redemption as an option.  I maintained the same credit limit from when the card account was previously a Reserve, so I expected a smooth upgrade experience.

I called the phone number on the back of my Freedom card, said “representative” a few times, and got a representative after a minimal wait.  As I was calling on the day of the official announcement, it was quickly apparent the representative was not up to speed on the changes and a bit hazy on the Reserve card in general.  I knew it immediately when she told me the Reserve annual fee was $525.  She corrected herself to $550 after bringing up the card info, and she proceeded to describe the normal benefits of the Reserve.

After she finished, I had noticed she did not bring up any of the new benefits.  I methodically brought up each of the new benefits, and she slowly confirmed my eligibility with the upgrade.  All in all, though, the upgrade went fine, and the representative said I will receive my new card in three to five days.

Chase Sapphire Reserve Upgrade

What’s Next

I also decided on the upgrade because I will be rewarded at a higher level for something I’m already doing.  Likewise, I will continue spending in the 5% categories for our Ink Business Cash and Freedom cards.  I’ve already maxed out the grocery categories on all Freedom cards, and I await the third quarter category announcement.  I’ll try to be as creative as possible to max out the Freedom categories starting in July.  Ink Business Cash spending is continuing as is my routine.  I plan to push harder on our four Ink Business Cash accounts over the Summer.

Looking Closer at Other Bonus Categories

Other than the 5% categories, I wanted to refresh my memory on the lower-earning bonus categories to determine if any were worth an increase in spending.  As I only now hold the Reserve, Freedom, and Ink Business Cash, I quickly came to the conclusion no other bonus categories were worth much attention from me.  The only area I may focus a little bit on is travel, which essentially increases to 4.5% back on the Reserve.  However, since I travel close to free, I don’t expect any significant use there, if at all.

For those of you interested in cashing out, there are some viable options to refocus your spending.  Here are a few (I’m listing the obvious ones first):

  • Freedom: 5% quarterly categories (currently grocery stores, streaming, gym memberships).  This turns into 7.5% cash back, laughably outpacing other card competitors.
  • Ink Business Cash: 5% categories (office supply stores and internet/cable/phone services).  Similar to Freedom, this turns into 7.5% cash back.  Cardholders should focus on restaurant and gas station spend if they aren’t earning at least 3% back otherwise.
  • Sapphire Reserve:  CSR holders should focus on travel and dining spend if they aren’t earning at least 4.5% back elsewhere.
  • Sapphire Preferred:  CSP holders should focus on travel and dining spend if they aren’t earning at least 3% back elsewhere.
  • Freedom Unlimited/Ink Business Unlimited:  Cardholders should focus all other spend on these cards if they aren’t otherwise earning at least 2.25% back.
  • Ink Business Preferred:  Cardholders should focus on travel, shipping, internet/cable/phone services, and advertising spend if they aren’t earning at least 4.5% back elsewhere.

Final Thoughts

This is a lucrative upgrade since I’m rewarded at a much higher rate for spending and redeeming I already conduct.  But will I keep the card after the first cardmember year?  There is discussion that the September 30th redemption deadline will be extended or made permanent.  I’ll then determine whether CSR stands for Chase Sapphire Reserve or Chase Sapphire Rental.  Have you upgraded or plan to?  How did you decide?

Benjy Harmon
Benjy is a fan of points, miles, and financial independence. An experienced world traveler, husband, and father, he currently focuses on roaming throughout the USA expense-free (or close to it). He enjoys helping others achieve their travel goals, Disney-related and otherwise.

More Like This

13 COMMENTS

Responses are not provided or commissioned by the bank advertiser. Responses have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by the bank advertiser. It is not the bank advertiser's responsibility to ensure all posts and/or questions are answered.

13 COMMENTS

  1. I upgraded my CSP to CSR and the rep told me the annual fee is $550 but I would be receiving a $100 credit after the annual fee posts. Did the rep not tell you that? I’m worried that it may never post for me as well because I have been reading that not many have been offered the credit for upgrading.

    • David,

      I wasn’t eligible for any $100 credit because I was upgrading from a Freedom to CSR. It seems like you can take what the rep said at face value, but just be sure to follow up if the credit doesn’t show up after the AF posts.

  2. “With a $142 upgrade cost, I needed to cash out at least 28,400 points to cover my upgrade cost from a Chase Freedom.” How do you calculate 28,400 points?

    $142 + $300 = $442, divide by 1.5 => 29,500 points

    • BOND,

      Points are normally worth $0.01 each. With CSR, you get 50% more value, or 0.005. 142/0.005 = 28,400 Points.

      • When you upgrade the Chase Freedom to CSR, are you also giving up to $300/year
        (5% on bonus categories) cashback on the Chase Freedom? Should that be included in the upgrade cost?

        • BOND,

          You are correct, and I assess it as a bird-in-the-hand situation (for me). I have the immediate guarantee of 50% more value on all Chase UR card spend with an upgrade to CSR. While I’m hopeful future categories will be in areas where Freedom spend is easy, there are no guarantees on what or how much I will be able to spend in those categories. Second, at the rate I earn UR points, my gain from the CSR bonus will vastly outpace the Freedom cap I can earn over the next year. Third, I already maxed out Freedom’s Q2 bonus category on this card (and all other Freedoms). Even if I hold CSR for one cardmember year, I can upgrade back to Freedom within Q2 2021. This would mean potentially only missing out on a max of $225 in Freedom rewards while holding the CSR (Q3 and Q4 of 2020, and Q1 of 2021). And finally, I hold four other Freedom card accounts which I plan to actively use while holding the CSR.

          • If you later downgrade your CSR back to the Chase Freedom card, does Chase refund a prorated part of the $550 annual fee?

          • BOND,

            Great question, and a good play if you/anybody can make it work. I don’t know that answer nor calculate it into my decision, as I’m fully planning on holding the CSR for one year as part of the upgrade. I’m not a fan of PC’ing within one year with any issuer, really. But everybody’s different. For what it’s worth, when going over the upgrade terms, the representative did not say it wasn’t possible to downgrade back within one year, but I don’t take that as approval either….

  3. Why explain benefits that you already knew? She could obviously read them as well, although she didn’t.

  4. Don’t forget to buy $1,500 in Groceries in June with your new C$R, (7.5x cashback for this spend).

    In addition, the $1,500 in grocery charges will allow you to redeem 100k UR from your C$R @ 1.5 Cents each once you’ve transferred UR’s from your other UR earning cards to the C$R.

  5. I downgraded my CSR to a freedom UL as I value doordash at 0 and don’t use lyft at home either.
    Different strokes……
    I also figured it has been over 48 months since I received a bonus for a sapphire product so can (hopefully) reapply for a new one when I can travel again.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Sponsored

  • MtM recommended tool to track & organize credit cards
  • Best card offers personalized for you
  • Track bonus deadlines, fee dates & 5/24 status
  • Full Travel Freely overview

Free Sign-Up

moomoo - 2 Free Stocks!

Brokerage app moomoo is offering 2 Free Stocks! Just open an account and fund with $500 to get your stocks! Super easy.
Grab your 2 free stocks now!
BoardingArea

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Join thousands of MtM readers who are subscribed to receive a once daily email with all of our posts. Never miss out!

You have Successfully Subscribed!