What Makes A Good Airport? Thoughts From The MtM Team
What makes a good airport? The answer to this will be highly subjective. No 2 people will agree. Just look at us! These are the thoughts of the Miles to Memories team members on the question of “what makes a good airport?” We had a discussion about good and bad airports the other day (after disagreeing with some of these opinions), so we decided to put this together to share with you. Let us know your thoughts!
Shawn
Favorite airport: LAS (or maybe SIN)
For me an airport is all about convenience and the passenger experience. I look at things like how long it takes to make a connection and how everything is connected. That makes such a difference in the experience. Older airports designed before security measures usually fail when it comes to this.
Location is also a huge factor as is public transport options and traffic in general. I like airport that make it easy to explore a city, especially when traveling internationally. Not every airport ticks all of the boxes but more modern airports tend to get most of this stuff right whereas older dated ones struggle to keep up.
Mark
Favorite airport: DTW
DDG
Favorite airport: Whatever gets me to where I’m going
Close to the city center, and connected with public transportation. Connectivity between terminals, without having to jump on a long bus or train ride. Having several lounge options (hopefully not over-crowded), so you have a place to stay before your flight, or between connections.
Benjy
Favorite airport: SFO or DXB
The airport trait I value most is location. While any facility can be renovated, cleaned, or otherwise improved, an airport’s location cannot. For this reason, I prefer airports such as Reagan Washington National Airport (DCA) and Dallas Love Field (DAL) for their superior locations in comparison to their local counterparts. Airports with excellent locations may not have the amenities others closeby may hold. But well-located airports help me preserve the asset that I value most – time.
Ian
Favorite airport: SFO or SEA
Living in a rural area, I have an appreciation for tiny regional airports for their ease of transit, and overall efficiency. They may be less stressful, but they are often missing the best ingredients of what makes a great airport. It’s hard to pinpoint that perfect combination of what simply feels right, but you can’t go wrong if you combine an open, airy terminal that isn’t crowded (especially if it includes awesome airplane or runway views) with at least a few excellent food vendors and efficient public transportation access. I think that does it best for me.
Ryan
Favorite airport: KUL
A few features make for a good airport, and I find them quite easy to accomplish. It should have lounges accessible to paying / Priority Pass members (not just “flying on our airline today” lounges), public wifi, easy connections from gate to gate or terminal to terminal, and ample seating (preferably comfortable!). Plus, it should be easy to find the 3 things passengers care about most: departure information, bathrooms & food. Big bonus points for efficient security procedures and moving walkways/sky trains.
What Makes A Good Airport? Final Thoughts
Within our team, we obviously have very different approaches on this topic. Is there something that is the most important to you? Must have a certain type of lounge? Quiet terminal or with gate announcements? Don’t care, and just happy to be traveling? Let us know what you think makes a good airport.
Lower Spend - Chase Ink Business Preferred® 100K!
Chase Ink Business Preferred® is a powerful card that earns 3X Ultimate Rewards points in a broad range of business categories on the first $150K in spend per year. Right now earn 100K Chase Ultimate Rewards points after Learn more about this card and its features!
Opinions, reviews, analyses & recommendations are the author’s alone, and have not been reviewed, endorsed or approved by any of these entities.
[…] Makes a Good Airport: This is an interesting read on Miles to Memories. I personally don’t like DFW airport because of the way it’s structured. If we fly on […]
How about a article listing what the MtM staff thinks are the worst airports? I’ll go first, EWR!
That’s a pretty safe pick! I won’t disagree given my terrible experience there recently.
Oh man, that would be easy for me. I basically thought about “the worst” and then imagined an airport that had everything different.
Mine is CIA – Rome Ciampino
LAS misses out on a LOT of points due to the off site car rental center and lack of rail to rental cars or vegas strip. They also lack some lounges that should be there and there is no onsite hotel. I’d rank it even with SLC or even TLV. Domestically people bad mouth ORD but it’s not really too bad, other than the international terminal train deal. DFW is really good as well, DFW might be the best transfer airport but they lose at lot of votes for lack of CLEAR at AA entry points. I’d vote for AMS -Schipol as a good airport that really ticks a lot of boxes, good lounges, good hotels onsite, good parking, good transfers, good security, good shopping and restaurants. LHR and CDG would be good but are just a big mess. LAX is also underrated as a good airport I think. I’m no fan of the AA “eagle’s nest” but with lounge access it’s OK. At the end of the day the best airport is one that will get you to where you are going without too much fuss and without crappy TSA wait times. I’d give ATL and DEN the award for worst TSA lines.
Agreed about LAS. Getting to and from the airport is the worst part of going to Vegas…aside from the trashy drunk idiots, taxi/Uber scammers, and smoke filled casinos. There’s no excuse for a rail link to the strip considering how close it is, or at least a better Uber process or an efficient shuttle system. One thinks the LV taxi mafia holds major sway. I’m also not a big fan of having to take a tram from terminal to terminal, it’s kind of confusing for someone not accustomed to not going there. The entire process of going to this airport raises stress level, and that’s a sign that’s it’s not a good airport.
I’m also a big fan of AMS airport!
FRA is pretty high up on my list. There’s good lounges, a fair amount of nearby shopping, a nice rail connection for both short and medium haul, and hotels within easy walking distance. They also have smoking areas that are clean and accessible. I’m a nonsmoker but sometimes travel with one so this really eases stress.
Christian – agree FRA is good. I used it a lot in the 2.5yrs I lived in Germany (even though MUC was closer, but FRA often had the connection I wanted). It’s quick and user-intuitive.
Even me, as one person, has different criteria so there is no one best airport. Some plausible criteria include:
1. not too much walking. This is not an issue for me but what about when I am 85 and not frail enough for a wheelchair but cannot walk long distances? ATL, AMS are examples of failures. ORD, while big, doesn’t have that much walking, particularly Terminals 2 and 3.
2. if being picked up by car. If so, LIT Little Rock Arkansas, OMA Omaha Nebraska, and MCI Kansas City fit the bill. MCI is a bit far from the city so maybe a tad less.
3. if taking public transit. If so, DCA Washington National or SIN Changi Singapore isn’t bad.
4. if making a connection, some airports are more interesting than others. Some also have a greater number of connections.
5. architectural design is nice to look at. EWR Newark is far uglier than IAD Washington Dulles or CDG Roissy Paris. By the way, who calls it Charles de Gaulle? If I take a taxi, I always say “l’aeroport a Roissy, terminal 2A”
Lounge options, efficient security/immigration, and location are the most important factors for me.
With a 6 hour layover at MCO what are the best eateries for a family of 5, with 2 adults and kids ages; 19, 12 and 7.